I can relate a little bit to unelected bureauocrats running our life
My father was the municipal clerk of our small township for 35 yrs living on a farm and farming part time. He saw many elected reeves come and go. Some wanted to run their own show. Some wanted guidance. My father did his best to acomodate both.
My brother, on the other hand went further abroad, meaning maybe 50 miles down the road. He eventually advanced to being the head administrator of a fairly large municipality, with perhaps 1 million citizens of all ages
I can remember him talking about two kinds of councillors and mayors. The 1st kind was a hands off type, constantly asking guidance to run regular council meetings, and asking a show of hands for all decisions with little to no debate. In other words he wanted to rubber stamp, get things done quickly and let the administration decide all the details, including the agenda, budget and any special projects.. If my brother made a convincing presentation very few questions were asked and voting was almost unanimous. My unelected brother effectively ran the municipality, as to what he thought was best with little to no opposition.
Then there was the person who constantly asked questions. Questions would be good if they were knowlegable, but most were spur of the moment questions off the top of his/her head. She had no expertise and asked really dumb questions that took into the wee hrs off the morning to complete a meeting. All meetings were held after working hrs as all councillors had day jobs.. If this kind of person asked legitimate questions then yes she was effective, But to take up time on nonsense was very wasteful, This person was rarely prepared to ask a qualified question, rarely if ever read the agenda before hand, and was in general poorly organized
So: That is my experience in small town Ontario, Canada
One let hired personal run the show, the other wanted to add input, but did not know what kind of question to ask, thus was usually voted down, and the unelected administration [my brother] still ran the municipality
I can't respond to larger and more important issues
The obvious question using the above as an example
To whom should unelected bureaucrats answer to, who have qualified expertise in all the various issues that need a decision
Would this result in another layer of gov't with no end in sight if somebody decided, this layer of gov't also needed guidance
In the matter of law enforcement we thought a search warrant signed by a judge was a reasonable check on unreasonable search and seizure, but that has proven ineffective. Then we had the war on terror which lead to the FISA court which also proved ineffective
The result was: My unelected brother running the municipality
My father was from a different generation. Difficult as it was, he tried to acomadate what the elected reeve wanted, but he was in a very small community where there were very few decisions, to be a well run community.
I think your average public "joe the plumber" simply wants it done efficiently and with a minimum of unwanted intrusion into their daily life
However, I see no way to escape unelected bureaucrats, who will intrude in your daily life some time
Does anybody have a reasonable solution???